Tuesday, February 7, 2017

A Musing on Rural Culture and Law School.

I will have to finish this later, as alas, I have other things I must do. This was a comment I was going to leave on a blog called "Third Tier Reality" that called out the University of South Dakota School of Law, my alma mater. I think that USD Law has A LOT of room for improvement, but I found that this particular blog post had a lot of factual mistakes and false assumptions that usually occur when someone from outside the "fly-over states" tries to analyze any happenings among Northern Plains folk. I am loathed to actually post the comment because, besides being too long, I know this particular blogger has a history of being abusive to any comment or commenter who disagrees with his viewpoint. So here it is:



"I know a lot of this blog is a very opinionated gimmick, so providing any sort of sound reasoning is unlikely to be helpful or change any minds, but nonetheless. South Dakota is very rural and sparsely populated. We are a western state and so there is a very distinct culture here, especially west river, that takes some getting used to. There has been a gold rush of lawyers coming from other states, believe it or not, but few stay for very long because of the culture shock and lack of "stuff to do."

The law school itself has had trouble keeping administrators and faculty because of its location in Vermillion, which is a very isolated, backward, and small town. That is one of USD's greatest challenges. Lawyers come from large cities and have a hard time adjusting to the "backward" culture of places like Vermillion (and I am not criticizing those who don't want to stay, believe me. I dislike Vermilion and was SOOO happy to get out). So if you are are an unemployed lawyer who is interested in living the farm life in a small town, or are a lawyer who grew up in a rural area, please, we seriously could use you! Even at the law school if you want a cushy, part-time tenured job.

The problem with employment is that literally everyone wants to pile into Sioux Falls, and actually, Dean Geu has expressed extreme frustration about that to us. Even Pierre (the capital) and Rapid City, which both have thriving legal communities have a hard time recruiting people and ALWAYS have job openings for lawyers. And trust me, unless you are talking about Indian Country, the rest of the state has PLENTY of money. Those farmers you look down on? They are probably millionaires. Out west you have ranching families that own hundreds, if not thousands of acres with mineral rights for uranium and other rare metals. Trusts/wills/estates is an incredibly high needs area and if you are willing to live in a tiny town and/or travel, you will not lack business. Indian Country (reservations--Indian Country is really what they call it) is in DESPERATE need of lawyers and judges, but the problem is the lack of infrastructure. The government will PAY you to work there. A friend of mine in the bottom of our class who hasn't even passed the bar yet is working there because they NEED people. USD Law School is really one of the only places that teach the necessary tribal law.

You also cite the lack of employment of lawyers at "Biglaw" firms of more than 25 lawyers, which just made me chortle, because there ARE none here. Maybe 5 in Sioux Falls. This is not "big law" country, which to me just indicates how out of touch you are with the needs of western states, like most Urbanites who analyze our state from the outside.

Now, I will admit, there is no love lost between me and the Administration of USD (they were terrible to me my third year), but I would never discourage a South Dakotan who wants to practice in South Dakota from going there. I would SERIOUSLY discourage anyone from any other state who can't afford/can't get into the schools in their locality, and who wants to return home to practice, from going to USD. You aren't going to get a job. It's that simple. Also, if you want to go to USD and work in South Dakota, be flexible with where you are willing to work for the first few years. If you are willing to do that, you will be employed. Seriously, I can't think of anyone who STAYED in SD and was willing to work somewhere other than Sioux Falls who didn't get a job, even the people who failed the bar.

The people who are unemployed are usually those who moved back out of state and tried to pass another state's bar and work in another state. Or the people like me who wanted to, or needed to stay in Sioux Falls where the competition is incredibly fierce for legal jobs partially because of out-of-state migration to Sioux Falls. USD is an infrastructure school, and its closure would be devastating to the state. I think one incredibly obvious factor that the ABA has completely ignored in analyzing the NATIONWIDE fall in bar pass rates is how many of students are Non-traditional students with children who are trying to juggle debt, and jobs, and family with going to law school. In the past, legal education assumed they were the sole concern of their students. Especially in rural areas like South Dakota, this is a HUGE issue. I will be interested to see how the ABA and legal education as a whole addresses this issue."   


I have so much more to say on this issue, but sadly lack the time at this moment. Please bear with me until I am able to update again.

No comments:

Post a Comment